CLOUD Act: why a server in France does not put your data beyond the reach of US law
Since 2018, a US law lets American authorities demand from a US provider the data it controls, wherever it is stored. What this changes for an SME or a local authority handing its data to an AI tool, and the four questions to ask before signing.

Article prepared with the help of artificial intelligence from our monitoring, then reviewed and approved by Christophe Delebarre before publication.
On 10 June 2025, before a French Senate committee of inquiry, the head of public and legal affairs of Microsoft France was questioned under oath: could he guarantee that French citizens' data entrusted to his company would never be handed to US authorities without the agreement of the French authorities? His answer fits in one sentence: "No, I cannot guarantee it." He added that it had never happened. Both statements are accurate, and that is precisely the problem: no American company can give that guarantee, because a 2018 law forbids it.
What the CLOUD Act says
The CLOUD Act (Clarifying Lawful Overseas Use of Data Act) was passed by the US Congress on 23 March 2018. It answers a specific case: in 2013, US prosecutors asked Microsoft for emails stored in its Dublin data centre, as part of a drug-trafficking investigation. Microsoft refused, arguing that the data was in Ireland and that US law stops at the border. The case went up to the Supreme Court. Before it ruled, Congress passed the CLOUD Act, settling the question in the government's favour.
The text is short. An online service provider subject to US jurisdiction must hand over to US authorities, under a warrant or subpoena, the data "within its possession, custody, or control", whether that data is stored inside or outside the United States. The test is not where the server is, but which company controls it. A US company and its subsidiaries around the world fall within the law, whatever country they install their machines in.
It is worth being precise about what the law does and does not allow. These are targeted requests, in criminal investigations, approved by a US judge: not blanket access to European data. The provider can challenge a request before a US court, under narrow conditions. It cannot refuse it. And no contract, no commercial promise, no confidentiality clause exempts it. That is the meaning of the answer given to the Senate: the company has no choice.
Why "server in France" does not settle the question
Many providers highlight hosting in France or in Europe. That is a good thing, and the GDPR pushes in that direction. But the location of the data answers one question, not the CLOUD Act one. A data centre in Paris or Marseille operated by a US company, or by its French subsidiary, holds data "under the control" of a provider subject to US law. The server is in France; the law that may apply to it is American.
Conversely, a European company whose parent is not American is, in principle, not subject to the CLOUD Act. A request from US authorities must then go through judicial cooperation between states, that is, through a French judge. So the question to ask your provider is not only "where are your servers?", but "who are you, and who owns you?".
What European law says
The GDPR anticipated the case. Its Article 48 states that a decision of a third-country authority requiring the disclosure of personal data is recognised in Europe only if it is based on an international agreement, such as a mutual legal assistance treaty. In July 2019, the European Data Protection Board and the European Data Protection Supervisor examined the CLOUD Act and concluded that a provider handing over European data on a mere US request, outside that framework, would be in conflict with the GDPR.
The CLOUD Act provides for bilateral agreements to organise such requests; the United Kingdom and Australia have signed one, the European Union has not. The framework agreed in 2023 between the Union and the United States covers commercial data transfers; it does not remove from US authorities the power the CLOUD Act gives them. The US provider remains caught between two laws. And you, as controller, remain responsible for your data whatever happens: it is you that the data protection authority, a customer or a public buyer will hold to account.
And where does AI come in?
This is where the question becomes concrete for an SME or a local authority. An AI tool does not merely store your data: it reads it. Every request sent to an assistant, every document summarised, every email rewritten passes through the language model doing the work. Most large general-purpose models are operated by US companies. A customer contract, a personnel file, a citizen's request submitted to one of them is, for the duration of the processing and sometimes beyond, "under the control" of a provider subject to the CLOUD Act.
The address of the server hosting the application therefore matters less than where the model runs, and which company operates it. A tool "hosted in France" that sends your texts to a US model has moved the problem, not solved it. That is the point of the rule we detail in our article on hosting citizens' data: whenever company or personal data is involved, the model is European.
What we apply ourselves
The Isalia platform is hosted in France by OVHcloud, a French company whose parent is not American. Whenever company data is involved, processing goes through a European model, hosted in Europe, under a processing contract. Each customer has an isolated space, encrypted with its own keys. No data is used to train a model. Processors are listed and disclosed. And nothing is sent or written into your tools without human validation. The details are on our trust and compliance page.
The real risk, and the right answer
Let us be honest: the probability that a US criminal investigation targets the data of an SME in northern France is low. The CLOUD Act is not a daily threat. It is a question you need to be able to answer, because you will be asked: by a key account in its supplier questionnaire, by a data protection officer, by a public buyer in a tender, and sometimes by the data protection authority. "Can you guarantee that our data will not be handed to a foreign authority?" If your answer depends on a US provider, it will be the same as the one given to the Senate. If you chose your providers with the four questions above, you can answer precisely, and in writing. That is what we prepare with you in a compliance assessment, or simply by discussing your situation.
Sources
- https://www.congress.gov/bill/115th-congress/house-bill/4943
- https://www.senat.fr/compte-rendu-commissions/20250609/ce_commande_publique.html
- https://www.edpb.europa.eu/our-work-tools/our-documents/letters/edpb-edps-joint-response-libe-committee-impact-us-cloud-act_en
- https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2016/679/oj
